Working Group on Avian Nomenclature
The Working Group on Avian Nomenclature (WGAN) is the International Ornithologists’ Union’s forum for monitoring the scientific names of birds. Its aim is to serve as an “honest broker” in avian nomenclature, and to work in the interests of all ornithologists. Stability in names and their spellings is a core goal. To achieve this, the WGAN
- advises and takes action on avian nomenclatural matters put to it by IOU members and all international ornithologists
- makes application to the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature (ICZN) to conserve or suppress names and their spellings in the interests of stability in nomenclature
- recommends, for consideration by the ICZN, modifications to the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature towards improving its working
- prepares, for general reference, lists of available scientific names for different ranks of birds (family, genus, species) for ratification by the ICZN
- offers an advisory and referee service on scientific nomenclature to avian checklists, manuals, field guides, journals, web sites and any other public medium using scientific names for birds
In the past, the WGAN, as the Standing Committee on Ornithological Nomenclature, focused its attention on applications to the ICZN to conserve threatened names in wide use. This role continues, but the WGAN is broadening its scope on other fronts. One is to interact with the ICZN to improve the working of the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature and the cataloging of avian names available for use in nomenclature. Another is to liaise with media and IOU members generally, and global checklist publications in particular, wherever guidance in avian nomenclature is required.
The WGAN does not, however, deal with avian classification in any form, either with the taxonomy of species and genera, recognition of orders and families, or the establishment of a world wide list of avian species and subspecies arranged in genera, families and orders.
Stability: Nomenclatur`s keystone
Scientific names are badges that communicate taxonomic identity. That is their essential purpose. To serve that purpose effectively, names need to stay stable through time and change only when identity shifts, through lumping or splitting. Such change is necessary to track the shift in identity; and it carries biological information about systematic relationships. Names are also regulated by the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature with the same objective: to maintain stability. One of its core principles for promoting stability – priority – is the precedence given to names and spellings first published for a taxon. On-going discoveries of early published names, nevertheless, occasionally upset, and thereby destabilize, familiar names in use today. In such cases, the imperative link between badge and taxonomic identity can be disrupted by often minor man-made rules that carry no biological information. Accordingly, wherever long-established and widely-used names and their spellings would be upset by its rules, the Code makes special provision to conserve those names. That purpose is set out in the Code’s short Preamble which is an integral part of the Code and which establishes the Code’s functions. Concerning stability, it says:
“Priority of publication is a basic principle of zoological nomenclature; however, under conditions prescribed in the Code its application may be modified to conserve a long-accepted name in its accustomed meaning. When stability of nomenclature is threatened in an individual case, the strict application of the Code may under specified conditions be suspended by the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature.”
The WGAN is guided by this approach and follows the Code in all its actions, in the tradition of its predecessor, the Standing Committee on Ornithological Nomenclature.
The WGAN is founded on the Standing Committee on Ornithological Nomenclature (SCON) of the former International Ornithological Committee (IOC); and it continues the SCON’s work today. Formed at the 10th International Ornithological Congress at Uppsala in 1950, the SCON was the oldest serving Standing Committee of the IOC. Founding members included Ernst Mayr (USA), Erwin Stresemann (Germany) and Finn Salomonsen (Denmark), the last two as subsequent Chairs. Since then Charles Vaurie (USA), Eugene Eisenmann (USA), Walter Bock (USA), Richard Schodde (Australia) and Frank Steinheimer (Germany) have taken turns as Chairs. Two of its longest-serving members, Ernst Mayr and Walter Bock, also served successively as Commissioners on the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature.
Over the past 25 years, nearly 20 applications to conserve in-use names and spellings have passed through the SCON and WGAN to the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature. All but one so far have been successful. Several other opinions on correct names, all in wide use, have been published in the journals Zootaxa and Bulletin of the British Ornithologists’ Club. Significant among them are
- conservation of Cacatua as the senior generic name for the white cockatoos
- conservation of the long-used Paradisaea and Paradisaeidae as the correct spellings for the genus and family of birds-of-paradise
- conservation of the long-used Aplonis as the correct spelling of the generic name for the Pacific glossy starlings
- conservation of Pedionomus and Pedionomidae as the generic and family names for the Australian Plains Wanderer
In 1994, Professor Walter Bock also published, on behalf of the SCON, a comprehensive list of family names in birds, with synonyms. This will form the basis for a future list of available avian family group names, to be submitted to the ICZN for approval in their Lists of Available Names in Zoology. It is accessible under the title “History and Nomenclature of Avian Family-group Names” on the Biodiversity Heritage Library website (http://digitallibrary.amnh.org/dspace/handle/2246/830?show=full). Other projects in the pipeline are a number of recommendations to the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature to improve the working of its Code. One presently being considered is the limitation of the Code’s official language to English, for efficiency, economy and to avoid ambiguity.
At any one time, the WGAN comprises a globally representative group of experts in avian nomenclature who are appointed by the President of the IOU for four year terms between IOU congresses; all are eligible for re-election. Business is run through a Chair, and is carried out at a formal meeting at each congress and by email between congresses. Approval for any action requiring a vote, such as a recommendation to the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature, adapts the system used by the Commission. Reports of the Group’s work for each inter-Congress term are placed with the Union’s President and secretariat. Like the SCON before it, the WGAN works as an independent advisory body on nomenclature in ornithology, unaligned with outside interests and answerable only to the International Ornithologists’ Union.
To service its functions, the WGAN is testing a question-and-answer section attached to its forum on the Union website. We urge all ornithologists needing advice or support in nomenclatural matters, to place your case on the Question and Answer section attached to the working group forum, with relevant references and a reply address or to contact the chair of the WGAN directly. We shall deal with your questions promptly.
Members for 2014-2018
Dates in brackets are when those members joined:
Dr. Richard Schodde, Chair (1982), Australian National Wildlife Collection, National Research Collections Australia, CSIRO, Australian Capital Territory 2601, Australia. Email: email@example.com
Peter H. Barthel, Germany (2014); Professor Dr Walter J. Bock, USA (1982); Edward C. Dickinson, U.K. (2006); Robert J. Dowsett, Africa (2006); Andy Elliott, Spain (2014); Mary LeCroy, USA (2002); Wayne Longmore, Australia (2014); Dr. Danny Meirte, Africa (2014); Dr. Isao Nishiumi, Japan (2012); Dr. Ricardo Palma, New Zealand (2012); Dr. Vitor Piacentini, Brazil (2014); Dr. Jaroslav Red’kin, Russia (2014); Professor Dr. Frank Rheindt, east Asia (2014); Dr. Frank Steinheimer, Germany (2006); Dr. Carlo Violani, Italy (1986)